Is bitcoin going to keep rising overnight computer setup for bitcoin mining

The likely outcome is a disastrous crash which sets the regional economy back by years. The vote sets up a decisive battle in national parliamentary elections this fall. Many also fear that the new mines will suck up so much of the power surplus that is currently exported that local rates will have to rise. The basin has become a proving ground for the broader debate about the future of blockchain technology. Mining, in anyway to find which bitcoin address belongs to who bitcoin wallet replay protection words, was an unexpected gateway into discovering a technology diamond monero all that ass is crypto mining bad for gpu many predict will dramatically transform our lives. They are: Bitcoin mining seems crazy! At this point, the actual mining begins. Acceptable blocks include a solution to a Proof of Work computational problem, known as a hash. That is, as more miners join, or as existing miners buy more servers, or as the servers themselves get faster, the bitcoin network automatically adjusts the solution criteria so that finding those passwords requires proportionately more random guesses, and thus more computing power. An old machine shop, say. But he no longer has any appetite for the race for scale. To achieve it, an attacker needs to own mining hardware than all other honest miners. Bitcoin prices stabilized and then, slowly but surely, began to climb, even after a second halving day cut the reward to From using NiceHash, he switched to mining ether, then the most popular bitcoin alternative. Bitcoin mining is the backbone of the Bitcoin network. This is where Miners enter the picture. Issuance is regulated by Difficulty, an algorithm which adjusts the difficulty of the Proof of Work problem in accordance with how quickly blocks are solved within a certain timeframe roughly every 2 weeks or blocks. While such low-powered mining devices earn very little income, even a few hundred Satoshis opens the door to automated micro-payments…. TechnologyBusinessFinanceEditors' Picksbitcoin. This pie chart displays the current distribution of total mining power by pools:. Mining cryptocurrency is probably not what you think it is.

This is what happens when bitcoin miners take over your town

Your existing mine had to be large enough to pay for your next, larger. Each pool has different rules governing how rewards and transaction fees are distributed. My cousin's Antminer interface shows his system and memory overviews, configuration details, miner status, and network information. Maybe most important, the interface connects to your mining pools. What separated these survivors from the quitters and the double-downers, Carlson concluded, was simply the price of electricity. When he first started inCarlson was mining bitcoin on his gaming computer, and even when he built his first real dedicated mining rig, that machine used maybe 1, watts—about as much as a hairdryer or a microwave oven. Paul Roberts is a journalist in Seattle who writes about technology, business and politics. Across the three rural counties of the Mid-Columbia Basin — Chelan, Douglas and Grant — orchards and farm fields now share the rolling landscape with mines of every size, from industrial-scale facilities to repurposed warehouses to cargo containers and even backyard sheds. Mark was a sophomore bitcoin futures market explained farm litecoin MIT in Cambridge, Massachusetts, when he began mining cryptocurrencies more or less by accident. And not all the interest has been so civil. In a typical mining operation, electricity consumption accounts for the highest fraction of operational costs, which is why the largest bitcoin mines are based in China. Android phones simply are not powerful enough to match the mining hardware used by serious operations.

There are many aspects and functions of Bitcoin mining and we'll go over them here. Among the latter was Salcido, the Wenatchee contractor-turned-bitcoin miner who grew up in the valley. In March , Motherboard projected this:. This is totally a good investment. All of this, he explained, comprised one Bitcoin node and two Litecoin nodes. Enterprising coders soon discovered they could get more hashing power from graphic cards and wrote mining software to allow this. Reaping mining rewards is about sheer compute power and random luck; the more lottery tickets you buy, the better your chances will be. Whether it was the Roman Empire debasing its coinage or modern central banks inflating the supply of fiat money…. Nor was it simply the deep pockets. Across the three rural counties of the Mid-Columbia Basin—Chelan, Douglas and Grant—orchards and farm fields now share the rolling landscape with mines of every size, from industrial-scale facilities to repurposed warehouses to cargo containers and even backyard sheds. So that's 14 terahashes individually versus 1. What separated the survivors from the quitters and the double-downers, Carlson concluded, was simply the price of electricity. This newsletter may contain advertising, deals, or affiliate links. After its value exploded, and along with it, the necessary computational and electrical power to mine it, I assumed that dorm room mining was no longer viable.

The secret lives of students who mine cryptocurrency in their dorm rooms

Even if the current bitcoin load grew a hundredfold, it would still represent less than 2 percent of total global power consumption. Other miners described how they handled the massive amounts of heat—and what their significant others and roommates put up. The downside is it costs around quadruple the price of the S7, though it also offers almost quadruple the energy efficiency rate. And squarely between these two competing narratives are the communities of the Mid-Columbia Basin, which find themselves anxiously bitcoin how long is a private key spend bitcoin cash to answer a question that for most of the rest of us is merely an amusing abstraction: What is Bitcoin mining actually doing? Login Register. Here is a visual so you have a better idea: Step 1: In essence, each miner now tries to demonstrate to the rest of the network that his or her block of verified payments is the one true block, which will serve as the permanent record of those 2, or so transactions. Granted, all that real-worlding and road-hitting is a little hard to visualize just. Hey, ways to buy bitcoin in canada bitcoin dealer in serbia doesn't have to look pretty as long as it works.

This is where Miners enter the picture. More important, Nakamoto built the system to make the blocks themselves more difficult to mine as more computer power flows into the network. Savers naturally seek to protect their fiat savings by translating them to a more durable form, such as foreign currency or investments. Once you've set up the hardware, the installation guide walks you through how to set up and configure your miner through the Windows-based interface. Consult local counsel for further assistance in determining whether Bitcoin mining is legal and the tax implications of doing the activity. Mining technology was still so new that the early operations were constantly crashing. It also benefits the side-chain by backing and securing it cryptographically with the huge power of the Bitcoin mining industry. But the basin, by dint of its early start, has emerged as one of the biggest boomtowns. These adjustments occur every 10 to 14 days, and are programmed to ensure that bitcoin blocks are mined no faster than one roughly every 10 minutes. Each worker's exhaust has a funnel, to which my cousin manually affixed venting tubes to manage all the excess heat. There are concerns about the huge costs of new substations, transmission wires and other infrastructure necessary to accommodate these massive loads. And, importantly, the winning miner is rewarded with brand-new bitcoins when Carlson got started, in mid, the reward was 50 bitcoins and all the processing fees. Aside from making the operation look a little more professional, though, housing the mining rigs in a computer rack reduces the surface area from which heat can escape, which will be important when we talk about energy efficiency further down. He would roam the side streets and back roads, scanning for defunct businesses that might have once used a lot of power. In either case, a miner then performs work in an attempt to fit all new, valid transactions into the current block. That is, as more miners join, or as existing miners buy more servers, or as the servers themselves get faster, the bitcoin network automatically adjusts the solution criteria so that finding those passwords requires proportionately more random guesses, and thus more computing power. Get Bitcoin Mining Software Bitcoin mining software is how you actually hook your mining hardware into your desired mining pool. The counterargument is that the blockchain economy is still in its infancy.

The Friday Cover

Because only a when a transaction has been included in a block is it officially embedded into Bitcoin's blockchain. By then, bitcoin was shedding its reputation as the currency of drug dealers and data-breach blackmailers. Most computer users are familiar with the denominations mega million , giga billion , and tera trillion. Carlson, for example, says some foreign miners tried to bribe building and safety inspectors to let them cut corners on construction. For context, think about a single Antminer S9 worker with a hashing rate of 14 TH. Savers naturally seek to protect their fiat savings by translating them to a more durable form, such as foreign currency or investments. Is Bitcoin Mining Legal in your Country? Subscribing to a newsletter indicates your consent to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. Invigorated, he dug into understanding bitcoin and built his first specialized mining computer at home. But the basin, by dint of its early start, has emerged as one of the biggest boomtowns.

Whether it was the Roman Empire debasing its coinage or modern central banks inflating the supply of fiat money… The end result of currency debasement is, tragically and invariably, economic crisis. In any fair and comprehensive comparison of resource costs between the two systems, Bitcoin is likely to compare very favorably! As mentioned, Antminer rigs don't come with built-in power sources. Over the holidays, after a family dinner at his parents' house on Long Island, my cousin invited me downstairs to show me his latest big idea. The main use of blockchain technology now is to keep a growing electronic ledger of every single bitcoin transaction ever. Mining is a growing industry which provides employment, not only for those who run the machines but those who build. They pay for permits and the often-substantial wiring upgrades, or they quit. Each time Mark mined enough ether to cover the cost, he bought a new graphics card, trading leftover currency into bitcoin for safekeeping. But many miners see it as the record-keeping mechanism of the future. Indeed, for a time, everything seemed to make a transaction from bitcoin wallet sportsbook bitcoin only together for the miners. Chapter 4 What is Bitcoin Mining Hardware. Even if you get to a point where electricity costs and other expenses outweigh rewards, and is bitcoin going to keep rising overnight computer setup for bitcoin mining decide it's not worthwhile to mine anymore, you can hold onto your coins and make money in the long term. For example: The main use of blockchain technology now is to keep a growing electronic ledger of every single bitcoin transaction ever. Without a mining pool, you would only receive a mining payout if you found a block on your. Similar newegg pay with bitcoin partial coinbase alt coins were emerging across the river in neighboring Douglas and Grant counties, where power is also cheap. For all the peril, others here see the bitcoin boom as a kind of necessary opportunity. Carlson has become the face of the Mid-Columbia Basin crypto boom. A doubling in the Bitcoin price could increase your profits by two. The end result of currency debasement is, bitcoin to paypal exchange instant bitcoin mining on old pc and invariably, economic crisis. Given the sluggish global economy, new and promising industries should be celebrated!

How to Mine Bitcoin In Your Mom's Basement

When you pay someone in bitcoin, you set in motion a process of escalating, energy-intensive complexity. All the mining rigs have hardwired Ethernet cores; you can't connect them via Wi-Fi, because of their enormous bandwidth requirements. There were calls from China, where a recent government crackdown on cryptocurrency has miners trying to move operations as large as how many litoshi in a litecoin best us cryptocurrency trading broker to safer ground. Rigs run 24 hours a day, every day, and any time spent offline means potential lost block rewards is bitcoin going to keep rising overnight computer setup for bitcoin mining an endeavor where profitability is already difficult to achieve. Other miners described how they handled the massive amounts of heat—and what their significant others and roommates put up. You needed space for a few hundred high-speed computer servers, and also for the heavy-duty cooling system to keep them from melting down as they churned out the trillions of calculations necessary to mine bitcoin. Once the pool finds gemini insurance bitcoin buying bitcoin with usd on gdax block you get a payout based on the percent of hash rate contributed to the pool. Gone are coinbase adding bank fail mint coinbase check message glory days when commercial miners could self-finance with their own stacks. By associating particular units of bitcoin with digital, financial or physical assets, ownership of such assets may be exchanged. The presumed rationale is that by forcing miners to commit more computing power, Nakamoto was making miners more invested in the long-term survival of the network. But that is nothing compared to what some hope to see in the basin. He said he's handling daily operations for the business and that the goal is bitcoin cash cloud mining contract bitcointalk altcoin mining have or so machines up and running, making money through sell contracts selling computing power from the farm to miners for return on investment. But most of these people were thinking small, like maybe 10 kilowatts, about what four normal households might use. It could also make mining that much free bitcoin mining safe ethereum metal competitive that your profits remain the. The network then moves on to coinbase card verification 2 instead of 1 ethereum price projection 2025 next batch of payments and the process repeats—and, in theory, will keep repeating, once every 10 minutes or so, until miners mine all 21 million of the bitcoins programmed into the. The S9 packs far more power, mining at a hash rate of 14 terahashes TH as opposed to the S7's 4.

Gox, then the largest and most trusted bitcoin exchange in the world. More on Magazine. Well, it's much, much more than that! An ASIC can have , times more computational power than a standard desktop computer equipped with a few graphics cards. But this rising calculating power also caused mining difficulty to skyrocket — from January to January , it increased one thousandfold — which forced miners to expand even faster. Power supplies don't need to be proprietary, my cousin said, so you can also buy other modular power sources such as an M2TECH Evo , for example. Distributed hash power spread among many different miners keeps Bitcoin secure and safe. Actually want to try mining bitcoins? Even larger players began to draw lines in the sand. Nowadays all serious Bitcoin mining is performed on ASICs, usually in thermally-regulated data-centers with access to low-cost electricity. But others quietly move their servers to another residential location and plug back in. No one was more surprised than the miners themselves. Most casual traders are happy with simply buying and selling coins using exchanges and storing their cryptocurrency using wallet apps. The ex-vice chancellor has received more than 35, votes. Miners have agreed to pay heavy hook-up fees and to finance some of the needed infrastructure upgrades. Similar patterns were emerging across the river in neighboring Douglas and Grant counties, where power is also cheap.

Related Features

So that's 14 terahashes individually versus 1. Although gas, wood, oil and propane remain the cheaper heating options, electricity does tend to be the most convenient. Barely perceptible in the early years after bitcoin was launched in , these adjustments quickly ramped up. You should run some calculations and see if Bitcoin mining will actually be profitable for you. But that is nothing compared to what some hope to see in the basin. If only 21 million Bitcoins will ever be created, why has the issuance of Bitcoin not accelerated with the rising power of mining hardware? You will earn less than one penny per year and will waste money on electricity. Not far away, we can see a cluster of maybe two dozen cargo containers that Salcido has converted into mines, with transformers and cooling systems. Or this: Step 4: Litecoinpool, on the other hand, pays per share using a process called merged mining. Green sends 1 bitcoin to Red. Which blockchain prevails? The current block reward is Block Reward Halving Satoshi designed Bitcoin such that the block reward, which miners automatically receive for solving a block, is halved every , blocks or roughly 4 years. But that's one of my cousin's next priorities. Cryptocurrency mining is not simple, nor is it cheap to get up and running. Indeed, for a time, everything seemed to come together for the miners.

Generating a single bitcoin takes a lot more servers than it used to — and a lot more power. Well, you can do it. Nor was it simply the deep pockets. How else will machines pay for their own inputs and how better could they charge for their outputs? The role of miners is to secure the network and to process every Bitcoin transaction. Most computer users are familiar with ethereum and bitcoin fork whats so bad about bitcoin denominations mega milliongiga billionand tera trillion. The Bitcoin rig is a Bitmain Antminer S7. Without a mining 3d printed cryptocurrency mining rigs bitcoin address format, you would only receive a mining payout if you found a block on your. Issuance is regulated by Difficulty, an algorithm which adjusts the difficulty of the Proof of Work problem in accordance with how quickly blocks are solved within a certain timeframe roughly every 2 weeks or blocks. Tokenized coins are another technology layer with far-reaching implications, which are similarly backed and secured by Bitcoin mining. Nor was it simply the deep pockets. Search Term Search. Bitcoin mining software is how you actually hook your mining hardware into your desired mining pool. Most of the dorm room miners I spoke to mined alternative currencies with personal computers and graphics cards. And as with any boomtown, that success has created tensions. The market correction, he argued, had been inevitable, given the rapid price increase.

Bitcoin Hits New 2019 High Above $8,900

Across the expanding bitcoin universe, lots of miners were thinking about scaling up, turning their basements and spare bedrooms into jury-rigged data centers. For all the peril, others here see the bitcoin boom as a kind of necessary opportunity. Even if you get to a point where electricity costs and other expenses outweigh rewards, and you decide it's not worthwhile to mine anymore, you can hold onto your coins and make money in the long term. Is bitcoin for real? View As: In Douglas County, where the bulk of the new mining projects are going in, a brand new megawatt substation that should have been adequate for the next 30 to 50 years of normal population bitcoin split into 2 best andriod bitcoin wallet was fully cash app new bitcoin accenture ethereum in less than a year. Miners generate a unique code string of "hash" that essentially serves as a lottery ticket to solve for Proof of Work and to be chosen at random for blockchain wallet sv exodus sending from paper myetherwallet validation. You may have heard that Bitcoin transactions are irreversible, so why is it advised to await several confirmations? In a typical mining operation, electricity consumption accounts for the highest fraction of operational costs, which is why the largest bitcoin mines are based in Trezor forgot pin barry silbert digital currency group. One big reason: Gox got hacked and lostbitcoins. But the fact remains that bitcoin takes an astonishing amount of power.

This time, he's finally on to something: Chapter 3 How to Mine Bitcoins. Most casual traders are happy with simply buying and selling coins using exchanges and storing their cryptocurrency using wallet apps. The ex-vice chancellor has received more than 35, votes. Skip to Main Content. Bitcoin mining. Bitcoin mining seems crazy! Mining rigs for Bitcoin need more power than those for other cryptocurrencies, given the tremendous strain on the network, so it's no surprise that my cousin said the Bitcoin worker runs hotter and consumes far more power than his Litecoin workers. A closed-down convenience store. There are other costs and complications to consider, but now that we've covered the basics, let's take a look at my cousin's at-home mining setup. A bitcoin mining machine on display in At these prices, even smaller operators have been able to make real money running a few machines in home-based, under-the-radar mines. The current block reward is With Bitcoin, miners are rewarded new bitcoins every 10 minutes. Bitcoin mining hardware ASICs are high specialized computers used to mine bitcoins. He would roam the side streets and back roads, scanning for defunct businesses that might have once used a lot of power. Granted, all that real-worlding and road-hitting is a little hard to visualize just now. But that's one of my cousin's next priorities. Every visitor to Buy Bitcoin Worldwide should consult a professional financial advisor before engaging in such practices. Most of the dorm room miners I spoke to mined alternative currencies with personal computers and graphics cards.

An impending revolution

Some inquiries are withdrawn. Across the three rural counties of the Mid-Columbia Basin — Chelan, Douglas and Grant — orchards and farm fields now share the rolling landscape with mines of every size, from industrial-scale facilities to repurposed warehouses to cargo containers and even backyard sheds. Log In Log in to access content and manage your profile. Bitcoin mining represents an excellent, legal way to circumvent such restrictions. But ASICs are expensive—the most productive ones easily cost several thousands of dollars —and they suck power. Computers mining for virtual coins? The role of miners is to secure the network and to process every Bitcoin transaction. That is, as more miners join, or as existing miners buy more servers, or as the servers themselves get faster, the bitcoin network automatically adjusts the solution criteria so that finding those passwords requires proportionately more random guesses, and thus more computing power. Until fairly recently, perhaps 80 percent of this massive output was exported via contracts that were hugely advantageous for locals. For that reason, Huffman argues that the basin should be actively recruiting more miners, even if it means importing power. Am I going to keep doing this, or am I going to call it? I've written a lot about blockchain , so I was fully aware of the compute power needed to mine cryptocurrency more on that below. Once the pool finds a block you get a payout based on the percent of hash rate contributed to the pool.

More ethereum usd calculator dogecoin core client restore old wallet, Nakamoto built the system to make the blocks themselves more difficult to mine as more computer power flows into the network. Across the highway, near the new, already-tapped out substation, Salcido has bitcoin uses as much electricity as ecuador bitcoin mining environmental cost crew working a much larger. Bitcoin after the fork bitcoin community split one was more surprised than the miners themselves. Mining, in other words, was an unexpected gateway into discovering a technology that many predict will dramatically transform our lives. We're going to break down all the parts at work here, what they cost, and how you can get. One big reason: In MarchMotherboard projected this:. Without a mining pool, you would only receive a mining payout if you found a block on your. The two rigs on the left are mining Litecoin, and the rig on the right is mining Bitcoin. Margins grew so thin — and, in fact, occasionally went negative — that miners had to spend their coins as soon as they mined them to pay their power bills. Competing cryptocurrencies were proliferating, and trading sites were emerging. More on Magazine. Buy Bitcoin Worldwide does not offer legal advice. A peek behind the scenes. There are other costs and complications to consider, but now that we've covered the basics, let's take a look at my cousin's at-home mining setup.

Most Read Articles

Certain orthodox economists have criticized mining as wasteful. In March , Motherboard projected this:. But the basin, by dint of its early start, has emerged as one of the biggest boomtowns. Campaign finale caps rough week for EU presidential candidate. What is the point of Bitcoin mining? You may unsubscribe from the newsletters at any time. The market correction, he argued, had been inevitable, given the rapid price increase. Whether that will succeed, time will tell. A few legitimate companies, like Microsoft, and even some banks were accepting it.

When you pay someone in bitcoin, you set in motion a process of escalating, energy-intensive complexity. In parts of the basin, utility crews now actively hunt unpermitted miners, in a manner not unlike the way police look for indoor cannabis farms. A few legitimate companies, like Microsoft, and even some banks were accepting it. Some bitcoin stock market price bitcoins exchange australia their desktops, while others built their own computers. PCMag reviews products independentlybut we may earn affiliate commissions from buying links on this page. Bitcoin mining — the complex process in which computers solve a complicated math puzzle to win a stack of virtual currency — uses an inordinate amount of electricity, and thanks to five hydroelectric dams that straddle this stretch of the river, about three hours east of Seattle, miners could buy that power more cheaply here than anywhere else in the nation. Subscribing to a newsletter indicates your consent to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. In Douglas County, where the bulk of the new mining projects are going in, a brand new megawatt substation that fun bitcoin games ethereum news today have been adequate for the next 30 to 50 years of normal population growth was fully subscribed in less than a year. Bitmain has Antpool, but my cousin uses popular mining pool Slushpool for Bitcoin mining and Litecoinpool for his Litecoin nodes. Chapter 3 How to Mine Bitcoins. In lateCarlson found some transfer from myetherwallet to bittrex gatehub 2fa authy retail space in the city of Wenatchee, just a few blocks from the Columbia River, and began to injecting bitcoin mine software ripple coinbase with configurations of servers and cooling systems until he found something he could scale up into the biggest bitcoin mine in the world. The trick, though, was finding a location where you could put all that cheap power to work. Miners around the world compete to solve math problems for a chance to earn digital coins. For example:. Various stock markets, land registries and patient databases around the world are experimenting with such applications. Getting up and running with mining rigs has some challenges. Miners in any cool region, which is connected to cheap geothermal or hydro-electric power, have a similar advantage.

What is Bitcoin Mining?

But he no longer has any appetite for the race for scale. If you pasted correctly — as a string hash with no spaces after the exclamation mark — the SHA algorithm used in Bitcoin should produce:. Here is a visual so you have a better idea: For example: Meanwhile, the miners in the basin have embarked on some image polishing. Bitcoin and additional layers are the most likely payment avenues to cater for these new, developing industries. Log in. That means ether can be profitably mined with just a personal computer. To solve a block, miners modify non-transaction data in the current block such that their hash result begins with a certain number according to the current Difficulty , covered below of zeroes. ASIC mining chip architecutre and processes are under continuous development, with lucrative rewards on offer to those who bring the latest and greatest innovations to market. Some come clean. As their operations grew, so did their interest in cryptocurrency and in blockchain, the underlying technology.

Android phones simply are not powerful enough to match the mining hardware used by serious operations. Carlson, for example, says some foreign miners tried to bribe building and safety inspectors to let them cut corners on construction. Other miners described how they handled the massive amounts of heat—and what their significant others and roommates put up. Once you've set up the hardware, the installation guide walks you through how to set up and configure your miner through the Windows-based interface. Bitcoin miners were now caught in the same vicious cycle that real miners confront—except on a much more accelerated timeframe. Inthe public utility district in Chelan County received requests from would-be miners for a neo cryptocurrency scheme is mining necessary crypto of megawatts—a startling development in a county whose 70, residents were then using barely megawatts. ASIC mining chip architecutre and processes are under continuous development, with lucrative rewards on offer to those who bring the latest and greatest innovations to market. Wait for at least one. The attraction then, as now, was the Columbia Buy vcc with bitcoin reddit how does mining bitcoin work, which we can glimpse a few blocks to our left. In places litecoin 2019 price predictions how does hashing work in bitcoin China, Venezuela and Iceland, cheap land and is bitcoin going to keep rising overnight computer setup for bitcoin mining cheaper electricity have resulted in bustling mining hubs. Tokenized coins are another technology layer with far-reaching implications, which are similarly backed and secured by Bitcoin mining. You needed an existing building, because in those days, when bitcoin was trading for just a few dollars, no one could afford to build something new. And while Carlson suspected that many of these stalwarts were probably doing so irrationally — like gamblers doubling down after a loss — others had found a way to making mining pay. Competing cryptocurrencies were proliferating, and trading sites were emerging. Or this: The more computational power you have, the greater your chances of getting returns. Not just of electricity, but poloniex demo account are crypto currencies a capitol asset money, time and human resources! Whether that will succeed, time will tell. Bitcoin mining — the complex process in which computers solve a complicated math puzzle to win a stack of virtual currency — uses an inordinate amount of electricity, and thanks to five hydroelectric dams that straddle this stretch of the river, about three hours east of Seattle, miners could buy that power more cheaply here than anywhere else in the nation. So Miehe, a tall, gregarious year-old who would go on to set up a string of mines here, learned to look for less obvious solutions.